The Bake Shop

We start baking early so our cookies and pies are ready when you arrive

The Bake Shop

Nothing puts a smile on the face more than a freshly baked cookie still warm from the oven.

When you arrive at Kitchen Kettle Village, you’ll find an assortment of flavors from snickerdoodle – a Pennsylvania Dutch Country favorite, to the Lancaster County traditional molasses snap, to the popular chocolate chip cookie. Buy a gingerbreadman cookie and decorate it yourself with an assortment of colored icings. The cookie case is filled with many other delicious cookie varieties along with monthly features and seasonal creations.

Lancaster County Whoopie Pies

Don’t forget another Pennsylvania Dutch Country favorite – a whoopie pie! Fluffy icing nestled between two cake-like halves in chocolate, red velvet, pumpkin, peanut butter, or chocolate mint – a delight for kids of all ages!

Shoofly Pie

No visit to Pennsylvania Dutch Country would be complete without a shoofly pie, an ooey-gooey Lancaster County tradition. Check out our Nutty Elsie Pie – a delicious cross between a pecan pie and a chocolate chip cookie, it really is too good to miss!

Visit us

Just follow your nose to the Bake Shop located inside the Jam & Relish Kitchen in the heart of Kitchen Kettle Village.

Buy Online

Craving our baked goods but can't visit? We can ship our shoofly pies, whoopie pies and cookies to your door! Click here.